= Fedora Linux Kernel Overview

include::{partialsdir}/unreviewed-message.adoc[]

:toc:

[[section-update-schedule]]
== Update Schedule

The https://src.fedoraproject.org/rpms/kernel[Fedora Linux kernel] closely
follows the upstream https://www.kernel.org/[kernel releases]. To see the
current versions in Fedora, https://apps.fedoraproject.org/packages/kernel[check
out the packages application].

=== Stable Releases

Stable releases of Fedora receive two types of kernel updates.

==== Stable kernel updates

The upstream kernel community support the latest major version with stable
updates (5.y.z releases). These updates are released approximately once a week,
although they can occur more or less frequently. Once the upstream kernel
community makes a stable release, Fedora builds it and submits it as an update
to https://bodhi.fedoraproject.org/updates/?packages=kernel[Bodhi]. These
updates are typically left in Bodhi for testing for several days before being
submitted to the stable updates repository.

==== Major kernel updates

The Linux kernel releases new major versions (5.y releases)
every few months. When this occurs, Fedora updates
to the new major version after a couple upstream stable releases. When the
updates are submitted to Bodhi, more time is allowed for testing than stable
updates to ensure there are no serious regressions.

=== Development Releases

The development versions of Fedora include Rawhide and the Branched release.

==== Rawhide

The Rawhide kernel is the latest git snapshot of Linus'
https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/torvalds/linux.git/[upstream
kernel.org tree]. On a frequent (often daily) basis, a new snapshot is built.

==== Branched

https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Releases/Branched[Branched releases] receive
updates at less frequent intervals than Rawhide. Early on in the Branched
release, it is typically using a pre-release version of the kernel, so each
Release Candidate (RC) is built for Branched releases. Once the kernel is
released, it receives stable updates just like the stable Fedora releases.


[[debug-kernels]]
== Debug Kernels

The Linux kernel offers a number of configuration options to make debugging
problems easier. However, some of these options have a performance cost so
Fedora does not always turn these options on. When the debugging options have
been turned off in the ``kernel`` package, a separate ``kernel-debug`` package
is produced with those options on.

=== Stable and Branched Kernels

Stable and Branched kernels always disable the debugging options.

=== Rawhide

Rawhide kernels enable the debugging options. However, each release candidate
kernel is built with debugging options disabled. Release candidate kernels
can be recognized by their release field, which always has the git revision set
to 0. As an example, ``kernel-4.16.0-0.rc7.git0.1.fc28`` is the 7th release
candidate kernel for Fedora 28.


== Policies

=== Out-of-tree Drivers

The simplest method by far is for the driver to get merged upstream in Linus'
kernel. Fedora constantly rebases to newer upstream releases, so inherits these
changes "for free" with little overhead for the Fedora kernel maintainers.

Adding external drivers to the Fedora kernel that aren't accepted upstream
requires an ongoing effort for the Fedora kernel team, so where possible, we
try to avoid doing so. In the few situations where it makes sense to do so,
there are several criteria that must be met.

* There must be reasonable demand for the feature for us taking on the burden
  of carrying the code until it gets upstream.
* Passes basic sanity checks (has been reviewed by at least one Fedora kernel
  maintainer).
* Has an upstream developer actively trying to get their code merged into Linus'
  tree.
* Has a Fedora developer responsible for keeping it up to date in Fedora.
* Causes no discernible overhead for Fedora kernel maintainers. Code that must
  be continually fixed up tends to end up getting dropped.
* Doesn't add new system calls or similar ABI defining characteristics. This is
  to avoid a situation where we could end up with incompatibilities between
  distros/upstream.
* How a symbol is exported needs to be accepted upstream first. This includes:
** Adding an EXPORT_SYMBOL to export something that previously wasn't exported
** Changing an EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL to EXPORT_SYMBOL
** Changing an EXPORT_SYMBOL to EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL
* In the rare case where we add exports that aren't upstream, we err on the side
  of caution and use EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL to export them. This is done partly as a
  deterrent for 3rd-party modules not to use them. (As they may go away in the
  future). The only exception to all of the above is in new not-yet-merged
  upstream code that's being added. New symbols get to be exported however the
  author intended.

=== Staging

The drivers in the staging directory of the Linux kernel are known to be in a
rough and incomplete state. For the vast majority of these drivers, the kernel
team considers it unsafe to build and ship them. We do not have the confidence
in the existing code, nor do we have the time to debug issues in known
problematic drivers.

As with every policy, there are exceptions. Fedora ships a few staging drivers
at the moment for various pieces of hardware. For the Fedora kernel team to
enable a staging driver, the following conditions must be satisfied:

* There must be substantive code review and improvement upstream. This means
  actual fixes, and not just stylistic changes.
* There must be a contributor willing to be assigned bug reports and deal with
  upstream.
* The contributor must be actively involved improving the driver upstream.
* The driver must not result in an undue burden on the kernel team. This means
  that if a large number of bug reports result from the driver, then fixes are
  not occurring upstream quickly enough.
* It must be understood that if any of these conditions are not met, or
  eventually fail to be met, the driver will be disabled.

=== Builtin Features

From time to time, the Fedora kernel maintainers get asked to build something
into the kernel. That is, the functionality is included in the vmlinux binary
that every Fedora machine runs as opposed to being built as a module that is
only loaded if needed. Given that it is loaded on every machine, we tend to
build functionality as modules as much as possible. While one person might need
the driver for an ATI card, another will not and having that built into the
kernel is wasteful for really no reason.

There are no set criteria that map exactly to whether something is built-in or
not, but they generally follow these guidelines:

* The option cannot be built as a module and is widely used
* The option is not a driver/filesystem and used by something that is a Fedora
  default
* The option is a driver and used by a wide variety of machines (keyboard/mouse
  drivers, VT support)
* The option is a filesystem and is used by all machines or is the default
  Fedora filesystem (tmpfs, ext4).

Again, the above are general guidelines but for the most part we try and limit
the overall size of the vmlinux that is loaded to a core set of functionality.

If you find that the Fedora configuration options are not sufficient for your
needs, you can rebuild the kernel and change options as you see fit. See the
documentation on xref:kernel/build-custom-kernel.adoc[building a custom kernel].


[[community]]
== Getting Involved

If you're interested in contributing to the development and maintenance of the
Fedora kernel, check out the https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Kernel[kernel wiki]
for more information.

[[mailing-lists]]
=== Mailing Lists

The mailto:kernel@lists.fedoraproject.org[Fedora kernel mailing list] is for
Fedora-related kernel topics only. This includes Fedora-specific packaging and
kernel configuration settings. For discussions about Linux itself see the
https://kernelnewbies.org/ML[Kernelnewbies mailing lists] or the
http://vger.kernel.org/vger-lists.html[Linux Kernel mailing lists].

You can subscribe to the Fedora kernel mailing list and view the archive on
https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/kernel@lists.fedoraproject.org/[
Hyperkitty].

[[irc]]
=== IRC

Users interested in the Fedora kernel hang out in the ``#fedora-kernel`` channel
on https://freenode.net[freenode].

'''

See a typo, something missing or out of date, or anything else which can be
improved? Edit this document at https://pagure.io/fedora-docs/quick-docs.
