Translate SPDX licenses to Fedora license tags, warn about "/"

"/" is deprecated everywhere, so warn about that.
Translation from SPDX is only used for fedora or epel targets.

The Fedora license list coalesces various license variants that have different
SPDX license tags into a single license tag. Most notably, this is done for the
39 BSD variants and 18 MIT variants on the Fedora good licenses list. When a
spdx→fedora mapping exists, it should always be unambiguous, because SPDX
considers any change in the license text to be a unique license, and Fedora is
more permissive in that regard.

To make a review of the translation easy, debug info is output to stdout, and
comments are inserted into the spec when some translation is required or when
there are problems with the upstream licensing.

The license list is pulled from the spdx project:
$ curl 'https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LUJuzGKC5K2yYuAg8S-2VYbS2dmg_4IlFdpqj7n9Ghg/export?format=csv&id=1LUJuzGKC5K2yYuAg8S-2VYbS2dmg_4IlFdpqj7n9Ghg&gid=138634715' > rust2rpm/spdx_to_fedora.csv

v2:
- apply "/" replacement always

v3:
- print to stderr
- use csv.DictReader
- filter out empty license lines

MANIFEST.in

@@ -1,3 +1,4 @@
 include LICENSE
 include data/*
+include rust2rpm/spdx_to_fedora.csv
 include rust2rpm/templates/*

rust2rpm/__init__.py

@@ -1 +1,2 @@
 from .metadata import *
+from . import licensing

rust2rpm/__main__.py

@@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ import jinja2
 import requests
 import tqdm
 
-from . import Metadata
+from . import Metadata, licensing
 
 DEFAULT_EDITOR = "vi"
 XDG_CACHE_HOME = os.getenv("XDG_CACHE_HOME", os.path.expanduser("~/.cache"))
@@ -253,6 +253,11 @@ def main():
         kwargs["date"] = time.strftime("%a %b %d %Y")
     kwargs["packager"] = detect_packager()
 
+    if metadata.license is not None:
+        license, comments = licensing.translate_license(args.target, metadata.license)
+        kwargs["license"] = license
+        kwargs["license_comments"] = comments
+
     spec_file = "rust-{}.spec".format(crate)
     spec_contents = template.render(md=metadata, patch_file=patch_file, **kwargs)
     if args.stdout:

rust2rpm/licensing.py

@@ -0,0 +1,53 @@
+import os as _os
+import sys as _sys
+import csv as _csv
+import functools as _functools
+
+SPDX_TO_FEDORA_CSV = _os.path.dirname(__file__) + '/spdx_to_fedora.csv'
+
+def translate_slashes(license):
+    "Replace all slashes with OR, emit warning"
+    split = [l.strip() for l in license.split("/")]
+    if len(split) > 1:
+        print('Upstream uses deprecated "/" syntax. Replacing with "OR"',
+              file=_sys.stderr)
+    return ' OR '.join(split)
+
+@_functools.lru_cache()
+def spdx_to_fedora_map():
+    with open(SPDX_TO_FEDORA_CSV, newline='') as f:
+        reader = _csv.DictReader(f)
+        return {line['SPDX License Identifier'] : line['Fedora Short Name']
+                for line in reader
+                if line['SPDX License Identifier']}
+
+def translate_license_fedora(license):
+    comments = ''
+    final = []
+    for tag in license.split():
+        # We accept all variant cases, but output lowercase which is what Fedora LicensingGuidelines specify
+        if tag.upper() == 'OR':
+            final.append('or')
+        elif tag.upper() == 'AND':
+            final.append('and')
+        else:
+            mapped = spdx_to_fedora_map().get(tag, None)
+            if mapped is None:
+                comments += f'# FIXME: Upstream uses unknown SPDX tag {tag}!'
+                final.append(tag)
+            elif mapped is '':
+                comments += f"# FIXME: Upstream SPDX tag {tag} not listed in Fedora's good licenses list.\n"
+                comments += "# FIXME: This package might not be allowed in Fedora!\n"
+                final.append(tag)
+            else:
+                final.append(mapped)
+                if mapped != tag:
+                    print(f'Upstream license tag {tag} translated to {mapped}',
+                          file=_sys.stderr)
+    return (' '.join(final), comments or None)
+
+def translate_license(target, license):
+    license = translate_slashes(license)
+    if target.startswith("fedora") or target.startswith("epel"):
+        return translate_license_fedora(license)
+    return license, None

rust2rpm/spdx_to_fedora.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,372 @@
+SPDX Full name of License,SPDX License Identifier,Fedora Short Name,Fedora Fullname (if different),Notes,Other Fedora Licenses (full name) that use same short identifier and are SPDX License List equivalent (as per SPDX Matching Guidelines)
+3dfx Glide License,Glide,Glide,,,
+Abstyles License,Abstyles,Abstyles,,,
+Academic Free License v1.1,AFL-1.1,,,not on Fedora list,
+Academic Free License v1.2,AFL-1.2,,,not on Fedora list,
+Academic Free License v2.0,AFL-2.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Academic Free License v2.1,AFL-2.1,,,not on Fedora list,
+Academic Free License v3.0,AFL-3.0,AFL,Academic Free License,,
+Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences BSD,AMPAS,AMPAS BSD,,,
+Adaptive Public License 1.0,APL-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+Adobe Glyph List License,Adobe-Glyph,MIT,,,
+Adobe Postscript AFM License,APAFML,APAFML,,,
+Adobe Systems Incorporated Source Code License Agreement,Adobe-2006,Adobe,,,
+Affero General Public License v1.0,AGPL-1.0,AGPLv1,,,
+Afmparse License,Afmparse,Afmparse,,,
+Aladdin Free Public License,Aladdin,,,not on Fedora list,
+Amazon Digital Services License,ADSL,ADSL,,,
+AMD's plpa_map.c License,AMDPLPA,AMDPLPA,,,
+ANTLR Software Rights Notice,ANTLR-PD,,,not on Fedora list,
+Apache License 1.0,Apache-1.0,ASL 1.0,Apache Software License 1.0,,
+Apache License 1.1,Apache-1.1,ASL 1.1,Apache Software License 1.1,,"4Suite Copyright License
+MX4J License
+Neotonic Clearsilver License
+Phorum License
+Sequence Library License
+QuickFix License"
+Apache License 2.0,Apache-2.0,ASL 2.0,Apache Software License 2.0,,
+Apple MIT License,AML,AML,,,
+Apple Public Source License 1.0,APSL-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+Apple Public Source License 1.1,APSL-1.1,,,Fedora bad list,
+Apple Public Source License 1.2,APSL-1.2,,,Fedora bad list,
+Apple Public Source License 2.0,APSL-2.0,APSL 2.0,,,
+Artistic License 1.0,Artistic-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Artistic License 1.0 (Perl),Artistic-1.0-Perl,,,Fedora bad list,
+Artistic License 1.0 w/clause 8,Artistic-1.0-cl8,,,not on Fedora list,
+Artistic License 2.0,Artistic-2.0,Artistic 2.0,Artistic 2.0,,
+Attribution Assurance License,AAL,AAL,,,
+Bahyph License,Bahyph,Bahyph,,,
+Barr License,Barr,Barr,,,
+Beerware License,Beerware,Beerware,,,
+BitTorrent Open Source License v1.0,BitTorrent-1.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+BitTorrent Open Source License v1.1,BitTorrent-1.1,BitTorrent,BitTorrent License,,
+Boost Software License 1.0,BSL-1.0,Boost,Boost Software License,,
+Borceux license,Borceux,Borceux,,,
+"BSD 2-clause ""Simplified"" License",BSD-2-Clause,BSD,BSD License (two clause),,Cryptix General License
+BSD 2-clause FreeBSD License,BSD-2-Clause-FreeBSD,,,not on Fedora list,
+BSD 2-clause NetBSD License,BSD-2-Clause-NetBSD,,,not on Fedora list,
+"BSD 3-clause ""New"" or ""Revised"" License",BSD-3-Clause,BSD,BSD License (no advertising),,Eclipse Distribution License 1.0
+BSD 3-clause Clear License,BSD-3-Clause-Clear,,,not on Fedora list,
+"BSD 4-clause ""Original"" or ""Old"" License",BSD-4-Clause,BSD with advertising,,See note re: BSD-4-Clause-UC (need to confirm w/Fedora),
+BSD Protection License,BSD-Protection,BSD Protection,,,
+BSD with attribution,BSD-3-Clause-Attribution,BSD with attribution,,,
+BSD-4-Clause (University of California-Specific),BSD-4-Clause-UC,BSD,,"Due to U. of CA 1999 retroactive deletion of the advertising clause, this is effectively 'BSD'-3-clause. Hence, Fedora would classify as “BSD” and not “BSD with advertising”? (need to confirm with Fedora)",
+bzip2 and libbzip2 License v1.0.5,bzip2-1.0.5,,,not on Fedora list,
+bzip2 and libbzip2 License v1.0.6,bzip2-1.0.6,,,not on Fedora list,
+Caldera License,Caldera,,,not on Fedora list,
+CeCILL Free Software License Agreement v1.0,CECILL-1.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+CeCILL Free Software License Agreement v1.1,CECILL-1.1,CeCILL,CeCILL License v1.1,,
+CeCILL Free Software License Agreement v2.0,CECILL-2.0,CeCILL,CeCILL License v2,,
+CeCILL-B Free Software License Agreement,CECILL-B,CeCILL-B,CeCILL-B License,,
+CeCILL-C Free Software License Agreement,CECILL-C,CeCILL-C,CeCILL-C License,,
+Clarified Artistic License,ClArtistic,Artistic clarified,Artistic (clarified),,
+CMU License,MIT-CMU,MIT,CMU License (BSD like),,
+CNRI Jython License,CNRI-Jython,Jpython,Jpython License (old),,
+CNRI Python License,CNRI-Python,CNRI,CNRI License (Old Python),Check – may not be exact match as per SPDX Matching Guidelines,
+CNRI Python Open Source GPL Compatible License Agreement,CNRI-Python-GPL-Compatible,,,not on Fedora list,
+Code Project Open License 1.02,CPOL-1.02,,,Fedora bad list,
+Common Development and Distribution License 1.0,CDDL-1.0,CDDL,Common Development Distribution License,,
+Common Development and Distribution License 1.1,CDDL-1.1,CDDL,,"This specific version not on Fedora list. Same as 1.0, but changes name from Sun to Oracle in section 4.1 and adds patent infringement termination clause (section 6.3) – would Fedora also consider “CDDL”?",
+Common Public Attribution License 1.0,CPAL-1.0,CPAL,CPAL License 1.0,,
+Common Public License 1.0,CPL-1.0,CPL,Common Public License,,
+Computer Associates Trusted Open Source License 1.1,CATOSL-1.1,CATOSL,,,
+Condor Public License v1.1,Condor-1.1,Condor,Condor Public License,,
+Creative Commons Attribution 1.0,CC-BY-1.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution 2.0,CC-BY-2.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution 2.5,CC-BY-2.5,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution 3.0,CC-BY-3.0,CC-BY,,,
+Creative Commons Attribution 4.0,CC-BY-4.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives 1.0,CC-BY-ND-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives 2.0,CC-BY-ND-2.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives 2.5,CC-BY-ND-2.5,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives 3.0,CC-BY-ND-3.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives 4.0,CC-BY-ND-4.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial 1.0,CC-BY-NC-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial 2.0,CC-BY-NC-2.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial 2.5,CC-BY-NC-2.5,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial 3.0,CC-BY-NC-3.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial 4.0,CC-BY-NC-4.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial No Derivatives 1.0,CC-BY-NC-ND-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial No Derivatives 2.0,CC-BY-NC-ND-2.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial No Derivatives 2.5,CC-BY-NC-ND-2.5,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial No Derivatives 3.0,CC-BY-NC-ND-3.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial No Derivatives 4.0,CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike 1.0,CC-BY-NC-SA-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike 2.0,CC-BY-NC-SA-2.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike 2.5,CC-BY-NC-SA-2.5,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike 3.0,CC-BY-NC-SA-3.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial Share Alike 4.0,CC-BY-NC-SA-4.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 1.0,CC-BY-SA-1.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 2.0,CC-BY-SA-2.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 2.5,CC-BY-SA-2.5,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 3.0,CC-BY-SA-3.0,CC-BY-SA,,,
+Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0,CC-BY-SA-4.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal,CC0-1.0,CC0,,,
+Crossword License,Crossword,Crossword,,,
+CUA Office Public License v1.0,CUA-OPL-1.0,MPLv1.1,,,
+Cube License,Cube,Cube,,,
+Deutsche Freie Software Lizenz,D-FSL-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+diffmark license,diffmark,diffmark,,,
+Do What The F*ck You Want To Public License,WTFPL,WTFPL,,,
+DOC License,DOC,DOC,,,
+Dotseqn License,Dotseqn,Dotseqn,,,
+DSDP License,DSDP,DSDP,,,
+dvipdfm License,dvipdfm,dvipdfm,,,
+Eclipse Public License 1.0,EPL-1.0,EPL,,,
+Educational Community License v1.0,ECL-1.0,ECL 1.0,,,
+Educational Community License v2.0,ECL-2.0,ECL 2.0,,,
+eGenix.com Public License 1.1.0,eGenix,eGenix,,,
+Eiffel Forum License v1.0,EFL-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+Eiffel Forum License v2.0,EFL-2.0,EFL 2.0,,,
+Enlightenment License (e16),MIT-advertising,MIT with advertising,,,
+enna License,MIT-enna,MIT,,,
+Entessa Public License v1.0,Entessa,Entessa,Entessa Public License,,
+Erlang Public License v1.1,ErlPL-1.1,ERPL,,,
+EU DataGrid Software License,EUDatagrid,EU Datagrid,,,
+European Union Public License 1.0,EUPL-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+European Union Public License 1.1,EUPL-1.1,EUPL 1.1,,,
+Eurosym License,Eurosym,Eurosym,,,
+Fair License,Fair,Fair,,,
+feh License,MIT-feh,MIT,,,
+Frameworx Open License 1.0,Frameworx-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+FreeImage Public License v1.0,FreeImage,MPLv1.0,FreeImage Public License,,
+Freetype Project License,FTL,FTL,Freetype License,,
+FSF Unlimited License,FSFUL,FSFUL,,,
+FSF Unlimited License (with License Retention),FSFULLR,FSFULLR,,,
+Giftware License,Giftware,Giftware,,,
+GL2PS License,GL2PS,GL2PS,,,
+Glulxe License,Glulxe,Glulxe,,,
+GNU Affero General Public License v3.0,AGPL-3.0,AGPLv3,Affero General Public License 3.0,,
+GNU Free Documentation License v1.1,GFDL-1.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+GNU Free Documentation License v1.2,GFDL-1.2,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+GNU Free Documentation License v1.3,GFDL-1.3,GFDL,,,
+GNU General Public License v1.0 only,GPL-1.0,GPLv1,,"For “or later” add + to SPDX or Fedora short identifier: 
+SPDX: GPL-1.0+ 
+Fedora: GPLv1+ or GPL+",
+GNU General Public License v2.0 only,GPL-2.0,GPLv2,,"For “or later” add + to SPDX or Fedora short identifier: 
+SPDX: GPL-2.0+ 
+Fedora: GPLv2+",
+GNU General Public License v3.0 only,GPL-3.0,GPLv3,,"For “or later” add + to SPDX or Fedora short identifier: 
+SPDX: GPL-3.0+ 
+Fedora: GPLv3+",
+GNU Lesser General Public License v2.1 only,LGPL-2.1,LGPLv2,,,
+GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0 only,LGPL-3.0,LGPLv3,,,
+GNU Library General Public License v2 only,LGPL-2.0,LGPLv2,,,
+gnuplot License,gnuplot,gnuplot,,,
+gSOAP Public License v1.3b,gSOAP-1.3b,,,not on Fedora list,
+Haskell Language Report License,HaskellReport,HaskellReport,,,
+Historic Permission Notice and Disclaimer,HPND,MIT,,,
+IBM PowerPC Initialization and Boot Software,IBM-pibs,,,not on Fedora list,
+IBM Public License v1.0,IPL-1.0,IBM,IBM Public License,,
+ICU License,ICU,,,not on Fedora list,
+ImageMagick License,ImageMagick,ImageMagick,,,
+iMatix Standard Function Library Agreement,iMatix,iMatix,,,
+Imlib2 License,Imlib2,Imlib2,,,
+Independent JPEG Group License,IJG,IJG,,,
+Intel ACPI Software License Agreement,Intel-ACPI,Intel ACPI,,,
+Intel Open Source License,Intel,,,Fedora bad list,
+IPA Font License,IPA,,,not on Fedora list,
+ISC License,ISC,ISC,,,
+JasPer License,JasPer-2.0,JasPer,,,
+JSON License,JSON,,,Fedora bad list,
+LaTeX Project Public License 1.3a,LPPL-1.3a,LPPL,,,
+LaTeX Project Public License v1.0,LPPL-1.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+LaTeX Project Public License v1.1,LPPL-1.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+LaTeX Project Public License v1.2,LPPL-1.2,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+LaTeX Project Public License v1.3c,LPPL-1.3c,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Latex2e License,Latex2e,Latex2e,,,
+Lawrence Berkeley National Labs BSD variant license,BSD-3-Clause-LBNL,LBNL BSD,,,
+Leptonica License,Leptonica,Leptonica,,,
+Lesser General Public License For Linguistic Resources,LGPLLR,,,,
+libpng License,Libpng,,,not on Fedora list,
+libtiff License,libtiff,libtiff,,,
+Lucent Public License v1.02,LPL-1.02,LPL,Lucent Public License (Plan9),,
+Lucent Public License Version 1.0,LPL-1.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+MakeIndex License,MakeIndex,MakeIndex,,,
+Matrix Template Library License,MTLL,MTLL,,,
+Microsoft Public License,MS-PL,MS-PL,,,
+Microsoft Reciprocal License,MS-RL,MS-RL,,,
+MirOS Licence,MirOS,MirOS,,,
+MIT +no-false-attribs license,MITNFA,MITNFA,,,
+MIT License,MIT,MIT,,,
+Motosoto License,Motosoto,Motosoto,,,
+Mozilla Public License 1.0,MPL-1.0,MPLv1.0,Mozilla Public License v1.0,,
+Mozilla Public License 1.1,MPL-1.1,MPLv1.1,Mozilla Public License v1.1,,
+Mozilla Public License 2.0,MPL-2.0,MPLv2.0,Mozilla Public License v2.0,,
+Mozilla Public License 2.0 (no copyleft exception),MPL-2.0-no-copyleft-exception,,,This variant not included on Fedora list (confirm this is correct statement),
+mpich2 License,mpich2,MIT,,,
+Multics License,Multics,,,not on Fedora list,
+Mup License,Mup,Mup,,,
+NASA Open Source Agreement 1.3,NASA-1.3,,,Fedora bad list,
+Naumen Public License,Naumen,Naumen,,,
+Net Boolean Public License v1,NBPL-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+NetCDF license,NetCDF,NetCDF,,,
+Nethack General Public License,NGPL,NGPL,,,
+Netizen Open Source License,NOSL,NOSL,,,
+Netscape Public License v1.0,NPL-1.0,Netscape,Netscape Public License,,
+Netscape Public License v1.1,NPL-1.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Newsletr License,Newsletr,Newsletr,,,
+No Limit Public License,NLPL,NLPL,,,
+Nokia Open Source License,Nokia,Nokia,,,
+Non-Profit Open Software License 3.0,NPOSL-3.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Noweb License,Noweb,Noweb,,,
+NRL License,NRL,BSD with advertising,,,
+NTP License,NTP,,,not on Fedora list,
+Nunit License,Nunit,MIT with advertising,,,
+OCLC Research Public License 2.0,OCLC-2.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+ODC Open Database License v1.0,ODbL-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+ODC Public Domain Dedication & License 1.0,PDDL-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Open Group Test Suite License,OGTSL,,,Fedora bad list,
+Open LDAP Public License 2.2.2,OLDAP-2.2.2,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v1.1,OLDAP-1.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v1.2,OLDAP-1.2,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v1.3,OLDAP-1.3,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v1.4,OLDAP-1.4,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.0 (or possibly 2.0A and 2.0B),OLDAP-2.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.0.1,OLDAP-2.0.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.1,OLDAP-2.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.2,OLDAP-2.2,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.2.1,OLDAP-2.2.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.3,OLDAP-2.3,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.4,OLDAP-2.4,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.5,OLDAP-2.5,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.6,OLDAP-2.6,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.7,OLDAP-2.7,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Open LDAP Public License v2.8,OLDAP-2.8,OpenLDAP,,,
+Open Market License,OML,OML,,,
+Open Public License v1.0,OPL-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+Open Software License 1.0,OSL-1.0,OSL 1.0,,,
+Open Software License 1.1,OSL-1.1,OSL 1.1,,,
+Open Software License 2.0,OSL-2.0,OSL 2.0,,,
+Open Software License 2.1,OSL-2.1,OSL 2.1,,,
+Open Software License 3.0,OSL-3.0,OSL 3.0,,,
+OpenSSL License,OpenSSL,OpenSSL,,,
+PHP License v3.0,PHP-3.0,PHP,,,
+PHP License v3.01,PHP-3.01,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Plexus Classworlds License,Plexus,Plexus,,,
+PostgreSQL License,PostgreSQL,PostgreSQL,,,
+psfrag License,psfrag,psfrag,,,
+psutils License,psutils,psutils,,,
+Python License 2.0,Python-2.0,,,"Stack of 4 licenses. SPDX version matches what is on OSI site. Fedora version looks to be more current version from Python website. May match, but need to check against SPDX matching guidelines (and possibly create template). SPDX could consider breaking indivicual licenses apart.",
+Q Public License 1.0,QPL-1.0,QPL,Q Public License,,
+Qhull License,Qhull,Qhull,,,
+Rdisc License,Rdisc,Rdisc,,,
+RealNetworks Public Source License v1.0,RPSL-1.0,RPSL,,,
+Reciprocal Public License 1.1,RPL-1.1,,,Fedora bad list,
+Reciprocal Public License 1.5,RPL-1.5,,,Fedora bad list,
+Red Hat eCos Public License v1.1,RHeCos-1.1,,,not on Fedora list,
+Ricoh Source Code Public License,RSCPL,,,Fedora bad list,
+RSA Message-Digest License ,RSA-MD,,,not on Fedora list,
+Ruby License,Ruby,Ruby,,,
+Sax Public Domain Notice,SAX-PD,,,not on Fedora list,
+Saxpath License,Saxpath,Saxpath,,,
+SCEA Shared Source License,SCEA,SCEA,,,
+Scheme Widget Library (SWL) Software License Agreement,SWL,SWL,,,
+SGI Free Software License B v1.0,SGI-B-1.0,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+SGI Free Software License B v1.1,SGI-B-1.1,,,Fedora bad list,
+SGI Free Software License B v2.0,SGI-B-2.0,MIT,SGI Free Software License B 2.0,,
+SIL Open Font License 1.0,OFL-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+SIL Open Font License 1.1,OFL-1.1,,,not on Fedora list,
+Simple Public License 2.0,SimPL-2.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+Sleepycat License,Sleepycat,Sleepycat,,,
+SNIA Public License 1.1,SNIA,SNIA,,,
+Spencer License 86,Spencer-86,HSRL,Henry Spencer Reg-Ex Library License,,
+Spencer License 94,Spencer-94,HSRL,Henry Spencer Reg-Ex Library License,,
+Spencer License 99,Spencer-99,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Standard ML of New Jersey License,SMLNJ,MIT,,,
+SugarCRM Public License v1.1.3,SugarCRM-1.1.3,,,not on Fedora list,
+Sun Industry Standards Source License v1.1,SISSL,SISSL,,,
+Sun Industry Standards Source License v1.2,SISSL-1.2,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Sun Public License v1.0,SPL-1.0,SPL,,,
+Sybase Open Watcom Public License 1.0,Watcom-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+TCL/TK License,TCL,TCL,,,
+The Unlicense,Unlicense,Unlicense,Unlicense,,
+TMate Open Source License,TMate,TMate,,,
+TORQUE v2.5+ Software License v1.1,TORQUE-1.1,TORQUEv1.1,,,
+Trusster Open Source License,TOSL,TOSL,,,
+Unicode Terms of Use,Unicode-TOU,,,not on Fedora list,
+Universal Permissive License v1.0,UPL-1.0,,,not on Fedora list,
+University of Illinois/NCSA Open Source License,NCSA,NCSA,NCSA/University of Illinois Open Source License,,
+Vim License,Vim,Vim,,,
+VOSTROM Public License for Open Source,VOSTROM,VOSTROM,,,
+Vovida Software License v1.0,VSL-1.0,VSL,,,
+W3C Software Notice and License (1998-07-20),W3C-19980720,,,not on Fedora list,
+W3C Software Notice and License (2002-12-31),W3C,W3C,,,
+Wsuipa License,Wsuipa,Wsuipa,,,
+X.Net License,Xnet,,,not on Fedora list,
+X11 License,X11,MIT,,,
+Xerox License,Xerox,Xerox,,,
+XFree86 License 1.1,XFree86-1.1,,,not on Fedora list,
+xinetd License,xinetd,xinetd,,,
+XPP License,xpp,xpp,,,
+XSkat License,XSkat,XSkat,,,
+Yahoo! Public License v1.0,YPL-1.0,,,Fedora bad list,
+Yahoo! Public License v1.1,YPL-1.1,YPLv1.1,,,
+Zed License,Zed,Zed,,,
+Zend License v2.0,Zend-2.0,Zend,,,
+Zimbra Public License v1.3,Zimbra-1.3,,,Fedora bad list,
+Zimbra Public License v1.4,Zimbra-1.4,,,not on Fedora list,
+zlib License,Zlib,"zlib
+Teeworlds",,,Teeworlds License
+zlib/libpng License with Acknowledgement,zlib-acknowledgement,zlib with acknowledgement,,,
+Zope Public License 1.1,ZPL-1.1,,,This specific version not on Fedora list,
+Zope Public License 2.0,ZPL-2.0,ZPLv2.0,,,
+Zope Public License 2.1,ZPL-2.1,ZPLv2.1,,,
+BSD Zero Clause License,0BSD,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+CeCILL Free Software License Agreement v2.1,CECILL-2.1,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+CrystalStacker License,CrystalStacker,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Interbase Public License v1.0,Interbase-1.0,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Sendmail License,Sendmail,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+curl License,curl,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.3, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Info-ZIP License,Info-ZIP,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.3, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Open CASCADE Technology Public License,OCCT-PL,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.3, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Open Government Licence v3.0,OGL-3.0,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.3, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Norwegian Licence for Open Government Data,NLOD-1.0,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+FSF All Permissive License,FSFAP,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Secure Messaging Protocol Public License,SMPPL,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Licence Libre du Québec – Permissive version 1.1,LiLiQ-P-1.1,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Licence Libre du Québec – Réciprocité forte version 1.1,LiLiQ-Rplus-1.1,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Licence Libre du Québec – Réciprocité version 1.1,LiLiQ-R-1.1,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+OSET Public License version 2.1,OSET-PL-2.1,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Free Art License 1.3,FAL-1.3,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Free Art License 1.2,FAL-1.2,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.4, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+BSD 3-Clause No Nuclear License,BSD-3-Clause-No-Nuclear-License,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.5, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+BSD 3-Clause No Nuclear License 2014,BSD-3-Clause-No-Nuclear-License-2014,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.5, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+BSD 3-Clause No Nuclear Warranty,BSD-3-Clause-No-Nuclear-Warranty,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.5, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+BSD Source Code Attribution,BSD-Source-Code,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.5, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+,,,,,
+,,,,,
+,,,,,
+,,,,,
+"License Exceptions: As per SPDX specification – these exceptions would use the short identifier for the main license, the “with” operator, and then the short identifier for the exception (shown here). See SPDX spec 2.0, Appendix IV",,,,,
+"389 Directory Server
+Exception",389-exception,GPLv2 with exceptions,Fedora Directory Server License,,
+Autoconf exception 2.0,Autoconf-exception-2.0,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+Autoconf exception 3.0,Autoconf-exception-3.0,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+Bison exception 2.2,Bison-exception-2.2,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+Classpath exception 2.0,Classpath-exception-2.0,[identifier] with exceptions,"On Fedora List as ""GNU General Public License (no version), with Classpath exception"" and ""GNU General Public License v2.0 only, with Classpath exception"" and ""GNU General Public License v2.0 or later, with Classpath exception"" and ""GNU General Public License v3.0 only, with Classpath exception"" and ""GNU General Public License v3.0 or later, with Classpath exception""","Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” ",
+CLISP exception 2.0 ,CLISP-exception-2.0,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+eCos exception 2.0,eCos-exception-2.0,eCos,eCos License v2.0,,
+FLTK exception,FLTK-exception,LGPLv2 with exceptions,FTLK License,,
+Font exception 2.0,Font-exception-2.0,[identifier] with exceptions,"On Fedora list as 
+""GNU General Public License v2.0 only, with font embedding exception"" and 
+""GNU General Public License v2.0 or later, with font embedding exception"" and 
+""GNU General Public License v3.0 only, with font embedding exception"" and 
+""GNU General Public License v3.0 or later, with font embedding exception"" and 
+""GNU General Public License (no version), with font embedding exception"".","Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+FreeRTOS Exception 2.0,freertos-exception-2.0,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+GCC Runtime Library exception 2.0,GCC-exception-2.0,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+GCC Runtime Library exception 3.1,GCC-exception-3.1,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+GNU JavaMail exception,gnu-javamail-exception,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+i2p GPL+Java Exception,i2p-gpl-java-exception,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+Libtool Exception,Libtool-exception,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+LZMA exception,LZMA-exception,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+Macros and Inline Functions Exception,mif-exception,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+Nokia Qt LGPL exception 1.1,Nokia-Qt-exception-1.1,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+Qwt exception 1.0,Qwt-exception-1.0,LGPLv2+ with exceptions,Qwt License 1.0,,
+U-Boot exception 2.0,u-boot-exception-2.0,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+WxWindows Library Exception 3.1,WxWindows-exception-3.1,[identifier] with exceptions,,"Similar to SPDX, Fedora uses the applicable license identifier and then “with exceptions” (this is not specifically on Fedora list)",
+DigiRule FOSS License Exception,DigiRule-FOSS-exception,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Fawkes Runtime Exception,Fawkes-Runtime-exception,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+OpenVPN OpenSSL Exception,openvpn-openssl-exception,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.2, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",
+Open CASCADE Exception 1.0,OCCT-exception-1.0,,,"added to SPDX-LLv2.3, so was not part of comparison to Fedora list",

rust2rpm/templates/main.spec

@@ -20,7 +20,13 @@ Summary:        {{ description_lines|join(" ")|trim }}
 Group:          {{ rust_group }}
 {% endif %}
 
-License:        {{ md.license|default("# FIXME") }}
+{% if md.license != license %}
+# Upstream license specification: {{ md.license|default("(missing)") }}
+{% endif %}
+License:        {{ license|default("# FIXME") }}
+{% if license_comments is not none %}
+{{ license_comments }}
+{% endif %}
 URL:            https://crates.io/crates/{{ md.name }}
 Source0:        https://crates.io/api/v1/crates/%{crate}/%{version}/download#/%{crate}-%{version}.crate
 {% if patch_file is not none %}

setup.py

@@ -10,6 +10,7 @@ ARGS = dict(
     packages=["rust2rpm"],
     package_data={
         "rust2rpm": [
+            "spdx_to_fedora.csv",
             "templates/*.spec",
             "templates/*.spec.inc",
         ],